Skip to content

Review of The Son by Philipp Meyer

June 14, 2013


It was with dread and anticipation that I picked up The Son by Philipp Meyer. There was no way that a book about a Texas oil and ranching family complete with marauding Indians could ever entertain or dazzle me, or so I thought. You never know though. Who would have guessed that earlier this year a book about reincarnation and Hitler would catch my fancy. Hello! Life After Life by Kate Atkinson certainly did. I had nothing to dread, it turns out. The Son moved me in a cataclysmic way.

This epic western novel is the multi-generational story of the McCullough family. The chapters alternate between three points of view moving back and forth over the course of 175 years. It’s a juggling act of characters and unfolding stories that builds tension simultaneously through space and time. How did he keep it all straight. An audience member at Powell’s asked him if he had used a big black board and a genealogy tree. Meyer said, “I did but those things don’t actually work very well. What happens is after a time you’ve just got to internalize the story. In fact if you don’t, it’ll never be good. I think that when you’re manually keeping track of things, you’re screwed. The thing’s never gonna work. The real work is done in your sub-conscious.”

SAMSUNG CAMERA PICTURESAlthough Meyer started out with eight characters, he threw out all but three. The first, Eli McCullough, is thirteen in 1849 when he is taken captive by the fierce Comanches after witnessing the rape and murder of his mother and sister. He soon becomes one of them adopting their ways, language, and even waging war against their enemies. Eventually, he returns to his roots, hungry for power, and stops at nothing to get what he wants.

Peter is Eli’s son and is the polar opposite of his father. He is bookish, passive, intellectual, and weighed down with a strong sense of morality. He carries guilt over the sins of his family. His voice is darkly wry.

Eli’s great-granddaughter is Jeannie, a woman who becomes tough in order to navigate the man’s world in which she chooses to move. She saves the family from bankruptcy, becomes one of the richest women in Texas, but makes sacrifices along the way.

The story is often brutal and bloody. There is murder performed in heinous ways. Torture is long and drawn-out. And, there is scalping–but it’s never gratuitous. Whereas, in some novels the blood is borne by evil men who have no redeeming qualities, Meyer’s cast of characters, including the Indians, never come across as soulless heathens. It’s more a case of those were the times, this was the culture, and that was the reality. There is sweetness, love, and tenderness on the Great Plains in enough quantities to make even a squeamish reader long for this story to last forever.

And the prose is smart and lyrical. At one point Peter thinks, “Perhaps this is why I am constantly disappointed–I expect good from the world, as a puppy might. Thus, like Prometheus, I am unmade every day.”

Philipp MeyerMeyer manages to express a sort of sympathy for all, including the white men, Mexicans, Germans, and Indians. They each come away looking as honorable as they are despicable. How does Meyer do this? It’s difficult enough to make a good character truly likable, but to make an unsympathetic character compelling is another thing.

One of the ways he achieves this, I think, is in the plethora of details that flush the story into a panoramic 3-D marvel. At Powell’s, Meyer talked about the hundreds of books he read during his research. He said he realized early on “how little I knew about the history of the American West, and Texas, and everything else.” But he didn’t stop there. Because he wanted an authentic voice, he needed to know what a buffalo looked like, what it smelled like, and what it tasted like. So he headed into the Texas dust for hands-on research. Meyer hunted deer with a bow and arrow, drank buffalo blood, and learned how to tan hides. He went to bed with a dictionary from 1880s so he could incorporate words from that time period into his characters language. A few days after Eli was captured by the Indians he says, “I had a dauncy spell but no one heard me over the wind.” It turns out dauncy is a word used to describe feeling icky. Rutting is the word Meyer used to describe having sex.

After five years of research and writing, Meyer finished The Son. But it turns out he wasn’t done yet. He told me he rewrote almost a third of the book after Ecco sent out the advanced reader copies. Later I read that some portions were rewritten 100 times. It shows.

I loved this book. It’s a riveting human drama full of love, hate, murder, renewal, blood, and lust. Yes, it’s entertaining, but more than that it teaches us something integral to the story of America. Meyer said, “Texas represents one pole of what the American mythology is…optimism…believe in yourself…” I learned a tremendous amount about the broken relationships between the disparate peoples of 19th-century Texas in The Son. I now know a lot more about different tribal customs than I ever did. And, when I was finished, I felt my attitude shift ever so slightly about all sorts of things, certainly about Texas, but also the Texas Rangers, slavery, immigration, and cattle ranching. It opened my eyes. I couldn’t put it down. It’s a Great American Novel if I ever saw one. I want it to win the National Book Award. Certainly, it will be an American classic. And probably a movie.

Ecco, 2013

  1. John McNeese permalink

    Beautiful. Thanks Diane.

  2. I would never have thought to read a novel about Texas, but now that I’ve read this review, I think I just might.

  3. Wow, that is a compelling review. With the lengths the author has gone to, and if he succeeded in then accessing the subconscious I have no doubt it is a powerful novel he has written.

    I also think that the western is coming back into vogue, certainly in the film world, with True Grit and Django. I’m a bit of a fan of McCarthy’s Border Trilogy, though I admit it is as much about his use of language as his subject, location and character. However, I shall be looking out for this one, thanks Diane. I hope it does well.

  4. As usual Diane has produced a first rate Review, this time in sharing her thoughts about a book by Phillip Meyer. Asked if he kept a “big black board and a geneology tree to keep track of multiple characters, Diane quotes Meyer: “I did but those things don’t actually work very well.” My thought is perhaps not for him, and perhaps not with any of his work. The black board and the geneology tree may work quite well for another writer.
    Diane continued with the Meyer quote: “What happens is after a time you’ve just got to internalize the story.” I agree with Meyer, and in this comment, I agree without a qualification.
    In Kentucky, the home of the famous derby there is a saying: “Different courses for different horses.” In the art and craft of writing, that rule also seems to hold: Find ‘the’, or ‘a’, process that works for you. Find material/ content/ stories about which you write best. Believe in yourself and your instincts and then start writing and keep writing.
    As for those who do not believe in what you write, or your talent as a writer or in you, think of the wisdom of the great Finnish Composer, Jean Sibelius, about critics: ” Remember, a statue has never been set up in honor of a critic.”
    Jim Dunne

  5. The Son MUST be the best read ever, after a review like that! Meyer is a helluva writer to keep readers straight on telling a 175 year long story. I already like this book because Meyer is serious enough about story accuracy that he tests his own via a deer hunt for book research. I totally agree with his opinion on trusting our subconscious to internalized thoughts vs a manual process. Our minds are more efficient than a white board and a dry erase marker.

  6. Until I read your review I wouldn’t have thought I’d pick up an epic western. But I will now. What a great review. I certainly trust your opinion… I’m 2/3 of the way through Life After Life, based on your earlier recommendation. What an astounding book. Again, I wouldn’t have thought killing off your character over and over would be so compelling. But the flip side is she comes to life in so many varied ways. Thanks for that! And, I’ve already put this one on my list.

  7. So glad to read this. I had it on my to-read list, but it was fast being supplanted by other novels that seemed more my kind of thing. Will go to it next!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: